Vol. 29 / No. 47 / CPIML MP Raja Ram Singh Demands Abolition of Wage...

CPIML MP Raja Ram Singh Demands Abolition of Wage Ceilings for ESI Coverage and Statutory Bonus

CPIML MP Raja Ram Singh Demands Abolition of Wage Ceilings for ESI Coverage and Statutory Bonus

CPI(ML) Liberation MP Raja Ram Singh has demanded the abolition of the arbitrary Rs 21,000 monthly wage ceiling that deprives lakhs of workers of healthcare, social security and statutory bonus entitlements. In two separate letters dated November 15 to the Union Minister of Labour and Employment in New Delhi, he called for the removal of these restrictions to ensure that workers are not denied their rights because of an outdated and unscientific wage threshold.

Comrade Raja Ram, who represents the Karakat constituency in Bihar in the Lok Sabha, demanded the abolition of the wage ceiling under the Employees' State Insurance (ESI) scheme and the removal of the wage limit for statutory bonus under the Code on Wages, 2019.

In his first letter, he pointed out that the Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) provides workers with medical care, sickness and maternity benefits, disability compensation and support for dependants in cases of employment-related death. Despite workers and employers contributing to the scheme, lakhs of workers remain excluded from these essential protections because of the wage ceiling.

The existing Rs 21,000 eligibility ceiling for ESI coverage was notified in December 2016 and came into effect on January 1, 2017. Raja Ram pointed out that while the costs of housing, food, transport, education and healthcare have risen sharply over the past decade, the wage ceiling has remained unchanged.

As a result, wage increases that merely compensate for inflation push workers out of the scheme even when their real incomes have not improved. A worker earning Rs 25,000 or Rs 30,000 a month cannot necessarily afford surgery, hospitalisation or prolonged medical treatment without financial hardship.

He argued that a worker in an urban area requires at least Rs 42,000 a month to live with dignity. A wage ceiling fixed at half this amount excludes workers who are themselves struggling to make ends meet.

Raising the constitutional implications of such exclusion, Raja Ram referred to the Supreme Court's 1995 judgment in Consumer Education and Research Centre v. Union of India, which recognised workers' right to health and medical care as part of the fundamental right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution. He also cited Articles 41, 42 and 43, which direct the State to ensure public assistance, maternity relief and a living wage. He argued that withdrawing healthcare protection on the basis of an arbitrary wage threshold is contrary to the constitutional principle of equality under Article 14.

In his second letter, Raja Ram demanded the withdrawal of the Rs 21,000 monthly wage ceiling for eligibility for statutory bonus under Section 26(1) of the Code on Wages, 2019.

The statutory bonus entitlement, previously governed by the Payment of Bonus Act, 1965, is now regulated under the Code on Wages. Raja Ram pointed out that the central government, through a notification dated August 25, 2026, retained the Rs 21,000 wage ceiling with effect from November 21, 2025.

The limit, originally fixed under the Payment of Bonus (Amendment) Act, 2015, has remained unchanged for more than a decade despite rising living costs and the erosion of workers' real wages. Consequently, workers whose wages increase merely to keep pace with inflation lose their statutory bonus entitlement.

Emphasising that bonus is not a gift from employers but the workers' rightful share in the surplus generated through their labour, Raja Ram pointed out that it has long been recognised as a form of deferred wages. A machine operator, technician or supervisor earning slightly more than Rs 21,000 contributes to the establishment's surplus just like other workers, yet is denied statutory bonus solely because of the wage ceiling.

He argued that such an arbitrary classification violates the constitutional principle of equality under Article 14 and contradicts the directive under Article 43 to secure a living wage and a decent standard of life for workers.

Comrade Raja Ram urged the Union government to immediately abolish both wage ceilings and ensure ESI coverage and statutory bonus entitlements for all workers, irrespective of their monthly wages.

Published on 17 November, 2026